Page 1 of 1

Crappy US Football Is Too Stop-Starty!

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 5:49 pm
by Jamz
Image

People in England always say about how American Football is far too stop-starty, but they’re fooling themselves.

The great thing about US football is that from the split second that whistle blows until (just after) if blows again, it’s 100% intensity and commitment. You have to have total awareness or you’ll get murdered.

I assume the people saying it’s stop-starty are comparing it wih rugby and soccer… when if you think about it for 90% of the game in those you’re jogging about half-assedly barely even paying attention. How’s that better than giving it absolutely everything you’ve got and then stopping to discuss the next best way to give it everything again?

Until you’ve played in full kit you really can’t appreciate how intense it all is.

When you’re playing, believe me when I say it doesn’t stop.

The other big whinge most Brits have is “They wear all that padding, the big puffs!”.

First off, I was watching some of the Six Nations rugby yesterday (my first time watching rugby in a long time), and I was very surprised to see that not only are a lot of players wearing head guards now, but many also appeared to be wearing shoulder pads?! So that’s pissed on your bonfire!

Having played both, I understand how totally different the two sports are. Sure, rugby is hard, but if you haven’t got the ball and have no intention of getting it, you won’t find some 300lb linebacker is suddenly all you see before sky, ground and pain.

Image

That ‘padding’ in US Football is also very convenient to use to try and hurt whoever you’re hitting. Again, if you haven’t played in full kit you’ll never be able to appreciate how hard people hit BECAUSE of the ‘padding’.

It’s a brutal game. It’s very tribal and primitive, and even much like a small scale war.

If you haven’t played it (and I notice that I’ve NEVER met anyone who’s actually played who still thinks it’s for pansies), then you’re missing out on an extreme experience!

And on that note, today is Superbowl Sunday!

Tonight, my favourite team – The Pittsburgh Steelers – will take on what is probably my second favourite team – The Green Bay Packers – in the Greatest Show On Earth.

It’s just a shame about the adverts….

Image

So I have beer and snacks in, and can’t -ing wait for what should be a great match up!

*waves his Terrible Towel*

Re: Crappy US Football Is Too Stop-Starty!

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 6:15 pm
by cargo
When Americian foorball first camr to UK TV on channel 4 I watched and enjoyed..................and I was a fan of the Packers

However it was ruined for me after trying to stay up watching the live Superbowl game it just went on and on and on eventually Igot bored

Sure it's tough and the big hits are certainly bit hits.................but there is plenty of recovery time...................rugby doesnt have that you take a hit and you get up for more or you lose...............thats why rugby is much much tougher.

Yesterday I watched the Ireland game and BOD was at the bottom of a maul/ruck he was the first man up and back into position and recieved the ball ploughed through two defence props to score........................


Think about say 10th phase ball in rugby..........that would take the best part of an hour in US football in rugby it's less that 5 minutes

Both are tough hard games but rugby is tougher and harder.



"Rugby is a good occasion for keeping thirty bullies far from the center of the city." - Oscar Wilde

Re: Crappy US Football Is Too Stop-Starty!

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 6:47 pm
by Jamz
In my experience of the two, US Football was definitely the tougher sport - but then I played with some proper psychopaths! :smt003 To be fair I liked it more so probably also put a lot more into it than I ever did with rugby.

For the Superbowl they do have a lot more breaks because it's all about the advertising. I think I heard in one of the build-up programs that they charge $7million for a 30 second advert slot!! shocking With those kind of figures I guess you can understand why, but I wish they'd just get on with the game.

Re: Crappy US Football Is Too Stop-Starty!

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 8:34 pm
by Tirpitz
I find that people who like Test cricket - as I do - don't have a problem with the length of an American Football game, which is really only a bit of a warm up in comparison......... geek

Re: Crappy US Football Is Too Stop-Starty!

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 11:57 pm
by Jamz
Tirpitz wrote:I find that people who like Test cricket - as I do - don't have a problem with the length of an American Football game, which is really only a bit of a warm up in comparison......... geek
Good point! If you're brought up on the game like the Yanks then that's all you know.

I'm sure they think a 90min footy game is a waste of good party time compared to the NFL experience!

Re: Crappy US Football Is Too Stop-Starty!

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 12:22 am
by cargo
I'm sat here watching the damn thing........................ :smt015

Re: Crappy US Football Is Too Stop-Starty!

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 2:38 pm
by Jamz
cargo wrote:I'm sat here watching the damn thing........................ :smt015
It was an ok game - nothing really too thrilling and no huge plays.

I'm sure I'd have enjoyed it more if the Steelers won...